Maria Crotty, Lynne C. Giles, Ian D. Cameron and Peter M. Brooks
Introduction
There is growing evidence that individuals with chronic diseases have difficulty securing employment (Petrides, Petermann, Henrichs, Petzoldt, Rolver, Schidlmeier, Webber, & Wendt, 1995), are more likely to drop out of the labour force (Doeglas, Suurmeijer, Krol, Sanderman, Van Leewuwen, & Van Rijswijkl, 1995; Mitchell, 1990; Yelin, Henke, & Epstein, 1987) and rarely have workplace adjustments made to assist them (Baanders, Andries, Rijken, & Dekker, 2001). With the ageing of the workforce the number of workers with chronic disease and disability will rise and the challenge to accommodate these groups in the workforce will increase. Of the chronic diseases the relationship between arthritis and work disability has probably had the most attention. National surveys examining arthritis have found that among people reporting symptomatic arthritis more than half will report some type of work disability (Dunlop, Manheim, Yeline, Song, & Chang, 2003). More than 40% of 8.78 million people aged 51-61 reported work disability in the US 1992 Health and Retirement Study (Yelin, 1995). A recent Australian review of the costs of arthritis used the National Health Survey to make estimates and found that arthritis is responsible for nearly 1.8 million days of reduced activity and about 213 000 days off work or school each year in Australia (Access Economics, 2001). The indirect costs including loss of earnings and lost production following premature retirement were triple the direct costs ($6.72 billion). Little however is known about how this compares to the impact of other disabling chronic diseases in Australia and little is known about the relationship of labour force participation with pain.
More work is needed to promote public policies, which are responsive to the needs of people with chronic diseases and more work is needed to promote an integration of clinical and social approaches. Secondary analyses of national data sets while constrained by a limited range of variables and the method of collection (which is often self report) give a picture of labour market issues.
In this analysis, using the 1998 Survey of Disability, Ageing and Carers (SDAC), we sought to examine the impact of musculoskeletal disease upon labour force participation and determine the effect of comorbidity and pain on workforce participation in a national sample of working age adults.
Methods
Data from the 1998 Survey of Disability, Ageing and Carers were used (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 1999b, 1999c). The subset of participants aged 15-64 years (n=25 217) were considered in this study. The Confidentialised Unit Record File distributed by the Australian Bureau of Statistics was used as the data source in these analyses (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 1999a).
A binary variable for labour force participation was created from the responses to questions concerning employment status and job seeking. Persons in full or part-time employment or looking for full or part-time work were defined as in the labour force. Persons not in the labour force included those who had retired, had family considerations, were full-time students or did not need or want to work, or were not participating in the labour force due to health and disability. Because our primary interest was in work disability, our conceptualisation of labour force participation focused on those respondents who were engaged in or seeking full or part-time employment, and those who were not in the labour force due to health and disability. Thus the usable sample comprised 19 496 persons.
We considered a range of possible predictors of labour force participation that were used by Badley and Wang (1998). Sociodemographic variables that we considered included age group, gender, education (currently attending school, incomplete secondary education, complete secondary education, missing), residence (capital city, other location), and family composition (couple only, couple with dependent children, couple with independent children, living alone, other).
Chronic conditions considered in these analyses included arthritis and musculoskeletal conditions, cancer, circulatory disorders, depression, diabetes, neurological conditions (excluding stroke), respiratory disease, hearing or vision (sensory) conditions, and stroke. The total number of chronic conditions was also calculated, and classified as 0, 1, 2 or at least 3 chronic conditions. We hypothesized that pain would be an additional independent factor influencing workforce participation (Badley & Wang, 1998). Participants' responses to a question concerning chronic pain were used to derive a binary variable indicating the presence or absence of pain.
Arthritis and other musculoskeletal diseases were examined in greater detail than other conditions because of their much higher prevalence and importance as an area for intervention (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 1999b). We considered a number of other chronic conditions to assess the effect of comorbidity with arthritis and musculoskeletal disease upon labour force participation. For arthritis, participants were classified as i) having no chronic conditions, ii) having arthritis and no other chronic conditions, iii) having chronic conditions but not arthritis, or iv) having both arthritis and other chronic conditions. A similar definition was applied for musculoskeletal disease excluding arthritis.
Analyses
All analyses were weighted, to take into account the unequal probability of selection for a person into the 1998 SDAC. The weights were derived from those supplied by the Australian Bureau of Statistics, and corrected to sum to 19 496.
Frequency distributions were initially tabulated for all variables. The prevalence of arthritis, musculoskeletal disease and chronic conditions among labour force participants and non-participants was plotted. The relationship between sociodemographic and health variables and labour force participation was examined using chi-square tests of association. Separate logistic regression analyses, controlling for the sociodemographic variables, were used to estimate the odds ratio (OR) of labour force participation associated with arthritis, musculoskeletal disease, and the number of chronic conditions respectively. The analyses were repeated including pain to assess its effect on the models.
Results
A total of 18 511 (94.9%) respondents were either engaged in or seeking full or part-time employment, while 985 (5.1%) were not in the labour force because of their health or disability. Table 1 summarizes labour force participation against the sociodemographic variables and pain. Chi-square tests of association showed that the relationship between labour force participation and each of these variables was significant (P<0.001), with the exception of gender, where a non-significant result (P=0.419) was found. Labour force participation generally declined with age, so that just over three quarters of the sample aged 60-64 were participants in the labour force, compared with almost 100 per cent of younger respondents. There was a strong relationship between non-participation and pain. More than one quarter of those with chronic pain were not participating in the labour force.
Table 1: Summary of labour force participation for sociodemographic variables and pain
in labour force |
not in labour force |
|
|||||
n |
%b |
n |
%c |
%d |
Total |
P-value |
|
Age last birthday |
|
<0.001 |
|||||
15-34 years |
8 400 |
45.4 |
139 |
14.1 |
1.6 |
8 539 |
|
35-49 years |
6 879 |
37.2 |
308 |
31.3 |
4.3 |
7 187 |
|
50-54 years |
1 728 |
9.3 |
187 |
18.9 |
9.7 |
1 915 |
|
55-59 years |
998 |
5.4 |
205 |
20.8 |
17.0 |
1 203 |
|
60-64 years |
505 |
2.7 |
147 |
14.9 |
22.5 |
652 |
|
Gender |
0.419 |
||||||
Male |
10 372 |
56.0 |
539 |
54.7 |
4.9 |
10 911 |
|
Female |
8 139 |
44.0 |
446 |
45.3 |
5.2 |
8 585 |
|
Education |
<0.001 |
||||||
Did not complete secondary |
10 090 |
54.5 |
805 |
81.7 |
7.4 |
10 895 |
|
Completed secondary |
8 421 |
45.5 |
180 |
18.3 |
2.1 |
8 601 |
|
Residential location |
<0.001 |
||||||
Capital city |
12 218 |
66.0 |
585 |
59.4 |
4.6 |
12 803 |
|
Balance of state |
6 293 |
34.0 |
400 |
40.6 |
6.0 |
6 693 |
|
Family Composition |
<0.001 |
||||||
Couple only |
3 554 |
19.2 |
254 |
25.8 |
6.7 |
3 808 |
|
Couple with dependent children |
5 924 |
32.0 |
110 |
11.2 |
1.8 |
6 034 |
|
Couple with independent children |
3 535 |
19.1 |
166 |
16.8 |
4.5 |
3 700 |
|
Lives alone |
1 434 |
7.7 |
202 |
20.5 |
12.4 |
1 636 |
|
Other |
4 064 |
22.0 |
253 |
25.7 |
5.9 |
4 318 |
|
Pain |
<0.001 |
||||||
Absent |
17 085 |
92.3 |
411 |
41.7 |
2.3 |
17 496 |
|
Present |
1 426 |
7.7 |
574 |
58.3 |
28.7 |
2 000 |
a: reported not in labour force due to health or disability
b: % based on those in labour force
c: % based on those not in labour force
d: row-specific %